Mars Hill Forum #143: What is the Nature of Politics and Freedom in Islam and Christianity?

John C. Rankin

On April 17, 2009, I had the delight to host a forum at South Church in Hartford with Alejandro Beutel of the Minaret of Freedom Insttitute. I had heard him address a meeting some time prior of the Center for the Study of Islam and Democracy in Washington, D.C., and respected, indeed, enjoyed very much is thirst for freedom. I rooted my definitions of politics as: “We have two choices in live – give and it will be given, or take before you are taken.” Alejandro rooted his definition of the political arena as: “Who gets what, when and how.” This definition does reflect Islam — namely, where rights are demanded from the government, whereas a biblical definition is whether government honors the prior unalienable rights of the people as given first by the Creator.

In our forum we had a good conversation, and here is an outline of the issues and questions I used:

  • Monad deity v. polytheism v. Trinitarian understanding.
  • Unity without diversity; diversity without unity; v, diversity in service to unity.
  • Historical verifiability of checks in balance in compilation of the Bible.
  • Singularity of Muhammad – all Islam trusts his solitary experience that had no checks and balances.
  • No historical witness in Qur’an prior; yet it claims to supersede the Bible.
  • Nixes Jesus as the Son of God – nixes the Trinity.
  • Is the State necessary to “protect” religion?
  • Expansion of Christianity v. expansion of Islam?
  • Classical Islamic definition of war and peace – “submit” to political hegemony.
  • Classical Islamic definition of land.
  • Any positive definition of freedom?
  • Freedom to convert?
  • Freedom of Muslim women to marry Christians?
  • Any Golden Rule in Islam?
  • One-way street?
  • Any concern for outsiders, other than to have them submit to Islam?
  • Any possibility of reformation, renaissance, in Islam?
  • Music + miracles?




Join Our Mailing List            John’s Speaking Schedule

logo_linkedin             youTube          

TEI International Leadership School

The foundation of Genesis 1-3 interprets the whole Bible, all church history, all political history and all world religions; indeed, it is the foundation for the most rigorous liberal arts education possible. Click here for the textbook: Genesis and the Power of True Assumptions (Volume 2), sixth book listed. Also see an outline of the seven classes taught in the TEI International Leadership School.


House of Lords 17 October 2017

Text of John Rankin’s address on the occasion of the 500th annive5rsary of the Reformation.